RSS

Monthly Archives: June 2013

Do you have a Fixed or Growth Mindset?

mindset

Over the last few of weeks, I’ve been reading Carol Dweck’s book Mindset: How You Can Fulfil Your Potential. Recently, I’ve been tweeting about the differences between a fixed and growth mindset: see #fixedvsgrowthmindset

Dweck’s research over 20 years has shown that the view you adopt for yourself profoundly affects the way you lead your life:

“In a fixed mindset people believe their basic abilities, their intelligence, their talents, are just fixed traits. They have a certain amount and that’s that, and then their goal becomes to look smart all the time and never look dumb. In a growth mindset, people understand that their talents and abilities can be developed through effort, good teaching and persistence. They don’t necessarily think everyone’s the same or anyone can be Einstein, but they believe everyone can get smarter if they work at it”.

Some other points that I took away from the book are that people with a fixed mindset:

  • Are measured by failure
  • Blame others or make excuses if they don’t perform well
  • Believe that effort is for people with deficiencies
  • Need to always prove their ability
  • Don’t want to confront their shortcomings
  • Stick with what they know in order to feel smart
  • Lose interest if things get hard

However, people with a growth mindset:

  • Believe their true potential is unknown – you can’t foresee what you can accomplish
  • Learn from their mistakes
  • Direct effort where they feel deficient
  • Enjoy challenges – they want to be stretched
  • Can develop their abilities through learning
  • Deal with failures and learn from them

Dweck also says that praising intelligence leads to a fixed mindset whereas praising effort leads to a growth mindset. Your background, upbringing and life experiences all help to shape your current mindset.

It’s likely that you’ll have a different mindset in different areas of your life. The good news is that you can change your mindset. It isn’t easy, you need to work at it but it’s worth it. The first step is knowing about the two mindsets and the differences between them. You can see from the above list how limiting a fixed mindset is compared to the growth mindset.

The second is making a conscious decision to think in a growth mindset when faced with challenges or setbacks or new situations. You should also use a growth mindset when giving feedback to or interacting with colleagues or staff in the workplace and family and friends in general. Your actions can help to shape the mindset of others.

Your mindset can have a powerful effect on your life. So, what mindset are you?

Reference:

Dweck, C. S. (2012). Mindset: How You Can Fulfil Your Potential. Constable & Robinson Limited.

Advertisements
 
5 Comments

Posted by on June 12, 2013 in Motivation, Theories

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Is Gamification the Answer?

Gamification

This post is based on a class presentation that I gave a few weeks ago as part of my educational psychology studies. My topic was ‘Video Games and Motivation’ and I looked at the research that has been done into the motivational pull of video game play and then linked this to gamification, which seems to be an increasingly popular technique being used in e-learning and other educational settings. From a personal perspective, learner motivation for e-learning is an important issue because its use in organisations is becoming more widespread.

In a TED talk on gaming, Jane McGonigal said that globally every week people spend 3 billion hours playing video games1. According to a Digital Australia report, it is estimated that by 2015 the global annual spend on video game activity will exceed $90 billion2. This is a huge amount of time and money spent playing video games. Most people who engage in video game play choose to do so voluntarily, because it is fun and they enjoy it. If people engage in activities because they enjoy them or find them interesting, then these activities are said to be intrinsically motivating. So for most, video game play must be an intrinsically motivating activity. One particular study has shown that motivation to play video games (regardless of the game type) is accounted for by how well the game satisfies our basic psychological needs of autonomy, competence and relatedness3.

As a term, gamification has existed for a few years and is defined as “the use of game design elements in non-game contexts”4. While some have interpreted gamification as turning learning experiences into games or adding games to learning experiences, the intent of gamification is not to create a game but to use elements of game design to increase motivation and encourage the learner to engage with the content. As video games involve the use of technology, it would seem that gamification would be readily adaptable to e-learning modules or virtual learning environments (VLE).

There is no prescribed list of game design elements or number of elements needed to ‘gamify’ learning but I would divide game design elements into two categories:

Mechanics of Video Games:

  • Rules/Goals: there is a defined structure and a clear set of goals
  • Challenge: there are challenges and for many, they increase in difficulty as play progresses
  • Mystery: there is an element of mystery that evokes curiosity in the player
  • Control: the player can regulate, direct or make decisions as they progress
  • Social interaction: having a social experience with other players

Aesthetics of Video Games:

  • Fantasy: an activity that is separate from real life
  • Sensory stimuli: dynamic graphics and/or sound effects to help create the fantasy world
  • Points/scoring system: received for completing parts of the game
  • Badges/Trophies: for accumulating points or completing parts of the game
  • Leaderboards: to rank players against their own performance or the performance of others

While gamification has been met with some criticism, it seems it’s more the application that’s the problem rather than the technique itself. This is because some applications have an aesthetics focus rather than a mechanics focus i.e. the balance between the two kinds of elements is weighted incorrectly. This is demonstrated by only using a scoring system or badges or leaderboards to make learning more game-like. Points and leaderboards assume that everyone likes to compete and be ranked but this is not always the case and if it’s not particularly challenging to accumulate points and badges it won’t be very motivating at all. It’s also lazy from a design perspective, as these things are easy to add-on. The mechanics of video games (while taking more time to design) allow for much more variety in terms of the learner experience. Points and badges and leaderboards will be the same from module to module but more can be done with different rules, goals, challenges, mystery and control options, which results in a different experience for each learning module.

An article that I read recently said, “the key to gamification is turning extrinsic rewards to intrinsic rewards”.  I would say that this statement is problematic because intrinsic and extrinsic rewards are so different. The intrinsic reward is your enjoyment as opposed to an extrinsic reward, which is something separate from the activity. People generally play games because they want to. People generally complete formal learning at work because they have to (it might be compliance training or to address a skill gap). These are the opposite in terms of reasons for engaging in learning. So even if the learning is gamified, will it have any effect on engagement if the learner is doing it because they have to? Also, gamification would benefit from further research into the motivational gains that should result from its use.

So, is gamification the answer to improving learner motivation when learning online? I think it could be but like all learning, it needs to be designed with the learner as the focus. The approach to gamification for a short stand-alone module would be different to a virtual learning environment (VLE). If we want to truly utilise gamification to its full potential we need to design learning experiences that satisfy basic psychological needs. I’m all for embracing new ways of doing things because they work and not because they are popular. I definitely believe that gamification a solution; it might be too early to tell if it’s the solution.

Have you used gamification in your e-learning projects? What did you do?

Can any topic area be gamified?

References:

1 McGonigal, J. (2010) Gaming can make a better world http://www.ted.com/talks/jane_mcgonigal_gaming_can_make_a_better_world.html

2 Digital Australia 2012, available at http://www.igea.net/2011/10/digital-australia-2012-da12/

3 Ryan, R. M., Rigby, C. S & Przybylski, A. K., (2006). The motivational pull of video games: a self-determination theory approach. Motivation and Emotion.  30, 347-364.

4 Deterding, S., Dixon, D., Khaled, R. & Nacke, L. (2011). From game design to gamefulness: defining “gamification”. In Proceedings of the 15th international Academic MindTrek Conference. 9-15.

 
5 Comments

Posted by on June 2, 2013 in Gamification

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

 
Learn. Show. Repeat.

Learn - Show - Repeat

John Stepper's Blog

Working Out Loud

Work Smarter Not Harder

Ask. Learn. Share | Mike Taylor's Weekly Tips & Tricks

LearnHaus

Knowledge is power and I intend to make us all powerful.

technologyinstructorblog

A topnotch WordPress.com site

LearnKotch

L&D from a different perspective

coffeeanDesign

let's have coffee & discuss the design...

Jackie Van Nice

E-Learning Goodness by Jackie Van Nice

Michelle Ockers

Continuously learning, and supporting others to learn

The Knowledge Project

making e-Learning a better experience

Ripple Effect Group

Be smart. Get social. Do business.

Learning Rebels

Lifting Learning in Workplaces Today

Learning as I go...

Just another WordPress.com site

Activate Learning Solutions

Making Work into Learning Experiences

Lost and Desperate

Random ramblings that might, or might not, relate to training, learning, development, and management

chat2lrn

Conversations to take learning forward

Learning in the Modern Workplace

Jane Hart's blog on modernising workplace learning

ISPI's 50th Anniversary

Where Knowledge Becomes Know How

The Hitch Hiker's Guide to Learning

Tripping through the galaxy of Learning & Development

fuchsia blue

learning development change

Building Creative Bridges

Training Learning Collaboration Innovation

Learningcreep

A blog to take my learning forward.

Gather with Purpose

intersection of community, learning and technology

Joanne Even's Blog

My journey through learning

Azhar's Reflections

Edu Journeys and Reflections

Julian Stodd's Learning Blog

A place to explore new ideas in Learning

%d bloggers like this: